Zettelkasten Forum


What is the Flow of Truth?

edited 8:41AM in Knowledge Work

In The Introduction to the Zettelkasten Method we read that using a Zettelkasten "is about optimizing your workflow of learning and producing knowledge". But what exactly does the introduction's author mean by "producing knowledge"? While searching for an answer here on zettelkasten.de, I noticed the phrase "flow of truth". I wanted to learn more about the idea that "truth" can "flow" or be transferred, so I searched more thoroughly. I hope that some readers find the following snippets interesting:

Comment 4021:

Apart from the pure Zettelkasten Method I explain what the core of argumentation means: A mechanism to transfer the assumed truth of a set of statements to a second. This is some (light) philosophy of knowledge stuff. I will translate it to what I call knowledge work (constructing arguments) and later demonstrate how it relates to structures in the Zettelkasten.

Comment 8076:

If you want to transfer truth from one statement to another, you need an argument to achieve this. No way around that.

Comment 8954

 (…) knowledge work is based on flow of truth and not like a legal text which is more concept orientated.

Comment 10651:

That means that you need to understand the flow of truth (e.g. how an argument transfers truth from one set of statements to another), the intimate relationship between arguments and evidence (e.g. How to marry rationalism and empiricism to breed beautiful children of knowledge).

Comment 14385:

This means that I create test code for the following aspects of writing:
3. the flow and manner of truth transmission. (…)

Comment 15130:

Progression in one's understanding leads to a change in the perception. Not the flow of notes is longer the mode of thinking but the actual flow of knowledge, truth, mapping etc.

Comment 15161:

I see books as a stock of contextualised building block of knowledge. My job is to de-contextualise (from the book) and then re-contextualise in my Zettelkasten. If the building block is has an empirical foundation I imagine a flow of truth through the events of the experiment, interpretation etc. into what I am claiming within my Zettelkasten. Going to the primary source would be similar to cutting an intermediary from the flow of truth.

Comment 23989:

Avoiding mastering the building blocks means avoiding developing critical thinking and system thinking skills. Critical thinking is term for one's ability to observe and create the flow of truth from empirical evidence, arguments to one's opinion. System thinking is a term for one's ability to observe patterns of feedback loops, relationship of wholes and parts and make sense of complexity.

No, I Do Not Underestimate the Power of the Dark Folgezettel:

2. I wasn’t conscious at all of the nature of knowledge while processing. For example, I didn’t highlight the flow of truth (e.g. making the logical form of the argument explicit) (…)

Sascha Fast: Die Zettelkasten Methode, 2025 (p. 109, machine translation):

2. What is the thought's relationship to truth?
a) What makes this thought true? Are there arguments? Is there empirical evidence?
b) What do the authorities say about the thought? Do they present arguments or empirical data? Are there everyday experiences that confirm the truth of this thought?

Regaining Depth With the Zettelkasten Method (Youtube):

So arguments and counter-arguments are how the truth flows from statement to statement. So knowing how to make arguments or formal arguments and provide counter-arguments and and stuff like that, is how to control the flow of truth.

I'm curious what you think about those snippets:

  • Have you clicked on some links and looked up the snippets in their original context?
  • How would you describe the flow of truth concept in your own words?
  • How would you determine if a statement, thought, idea, or knowledge building block is "true"?
  • Do you use the flow of truth concept in your own knowledge work? If yes, could you share examples?

Comments

  • These are good questions about applied logic and epistemology in Zettelkasten work. These questions are a good (partial) test of whether one is working at Level 4 in Sascha's "Complete Guide to Atomic Note-Taking". If you are completely perplexed about how to answer these questions, you're probably not working at Level 4.

    A partial answer to some of the questions: I would say that the flow of truth is an ideal taken from formal deductive arguments. If I'm working with factual, not purely formal, ideas, and with nondeductive arguments, then what flows between statements is acceptability, plausibility, weight, or warrant. We can still call that "truth" roughly speaking, but it's presumed factual truth rather than formal truth, so it may be better to use one of those aforementioned terms instead. So instead of asking "How would you determine if an idea is true?", I would ask "How would you determine if an idea is (or to what degree it is) acceptable or plausible or warranted?" To make this determination, you have to classify what kind of idea it is and find whatever standards of truth, acceptability, etc., apply to that kind of idea. For formal deductive arguments, deductive logic provides good standards, but for other kinds of ideas other standards apply.

  • edited 4:50PM

    I'd like to document two more sources for future reference.

    Analog vs. Digital Zettelkasten with Sascha Fast (Youtube):

    I have a really simple working definition. Arguments is a structure that transport the truth of one set of statements to another statement. That's basically it. Of course there are different kind of arguments, different forms, but it's basically a truth transport mechanism.

    The Iceberg Theory of the Zettelkasten Method — Exploring the Depths:

    Arguments are constructs to transfer the truth of some statements (the basic assumptions) to another (the conclusion). I must therefore ensure that the basic assumptions are true (by means of further arguments and empirical evidence) and that the transfer of truth is correct.

  • @Andy, my favorite umbrella term is reliability. :)

    I am a Zettler

  • @Andy said:
    A partial answer to some of the questions: I would say that the flow of truth is an ideal taken from formal deductive arguments. If I'm working with factual, not purely formal, ideas, and with nondeductive arguments, then what flows between statements is acceptability, plausibility, weight, or warrant. We can still call that "truth" roughly speaking, but it's presumed factual truth rather than formal truth, so it may be better to use one of those aforementioned terms instead.

    I have a somewhat different view of arguments, and the concept of "flow" only comes in indirectly. I'll set down a short summary.

    1. Purpose of an Argument Is To Justify A Thesis
      As a special case, the purpose of a rhetorical argument is usually to persuade or induce belief, rather than to prove or justify.
    2. An argument consists of a Claim or Thesis, along with a Justification for the claim.
      • In practice, the justification will involve a sequence of steps, each with its own claim(s) and justifications.
      • I define a claim as a (step, justification) pair.
      • This definition provides a basis for formally assessing an argument.
    3. So ... An Argument is a Sequence of (Claim, Transformation) Steps
      • Each step may be recursive to try to establish sufficient justification.
    4. There are various types of arguments. Most common types:
      • Deductive -- mathematical, logical
      • Abductive -- well-grounded; most scientific, technical arguments
      • Inductive -- generalization, analogical
      • Rhetorical -- persuation, intended to guide one to a result that is not well-justified.
        Rhetorical arguments often try to engage emotions to bypass solid justification.
    5. Arguments can be assessed using several axes:
      Dependability = (P × C × E) == (Plausibility × Confidence × Entailment)

      P, C, E are treated as linguistic variables.
      - They could be numeric on a scale of (0, 1) but there is no good reason to try to be so precise nor a good way to assign numerical values.

      (Note that the symbol × denotes a Cartesian product, not ordinary multiplication).

      The Axes
      - Plausibility ∈ [Definite, very plausible, plausible, dubious, unlikely, impossible]
      - Confidence ∈ [Certain, somewhat-certain, uncertain, very-uncertain, file-not-found]
      - Entailment ∈ [Logical, Reasonable, Weak, None]

      Ordering Dependability is a partial ordering.
      - Each dimension is ordered according to the order its members are listed in.

      Plausibility Truth value: corresponds to the estimate in a measurement.

      Confidence corresponds to the confidence band in a measurement.

      Entailment represents the strictness of a transformation from one statement to another.
      - Logical corresponds to logical deduction, the strongest level of entailment.

    The Confidence axis is important, different from Plausibility (or truth value) and often ignored. For example, a claim can be plausible but its support is uncertain.

    Any axis can be assessed independently from the others. A suitable Evaluation Function of a series of steps (e.g., transformations) is the minimization function min(s1, s2, ...).

    For example, take a series of Plausibility values P = [definite, dubious, plausible].

    EV(P) = min(P) = dubious.

    The min() function is the most optimistic evaluator possible. It acts as if all values except the least one have their maximum values. Any other evaluator function would assign lower values to the evaluation. This idea is illustrated by the saying "A chain is only as strong as its weakest link".

    An argument can consist of a series of steps, so one could say there is a "flow" in that sense. But the sequence is constructed in the service of justifying the thesis, not for transforming ideas per se to come up with other ideas (of course, that might happen, but it would be a side effect of the effort to work out the justifications).

  • edited 8:38PM

    @Andy said:
    (…) the flow of truth is an ideal taken from formal deductive arguments.

    Yes, makes sense. But what is the practical value of this ideal?

    @Andy said:
    If I'm working with factual, not purely formal, ideas, and with nondeductive arguments, then what flows between statements is acceptability, plausibility, weight, or warrant.

    I'm having difficulties with "flow". Is it a metaphor? Are there more technical terms for the same thing?

    And how would such a flow look like in Zettelkasten practice? Where would it appear in my notes?

    I learn best with examples. ;-)

    @Andy said:
    So instead of asking "How would you determine if an idea is true?", I would ask "How would you determine if an idea is (or to what degree it is) acceptable or plausible or warranted?"

    That's how I do it in my Zettelkasten. In addition, I limit the scope of my claims with "… for the purposes of my zettelkasten".

    However, the word "truth" is non-negotiable. ;-) When you look at the quotes, "truth" is the common element. So what is "truth" in "knowledge work"?

    An example would be really nice, preferably using knowledge building blocks.

    @Andy said:
    For formal deductive arguments, deductive logic provides good standards, but for other kinds of ideas other standards apply.

    Yes!

Sign In or Register to comment.