Zettelkasten vs One Big Text File
I'm interested if anyone has tried using "One Big Text File" for their writing, rather than the multiple individual text files of a Zettelkasten.
I like the idea of capturing interesting things in one file, then over time copy/pasting them around into similar groups. I imagine that over time organic structure and themes would emerge.
The main use I see for this would be if you have a particular writing project that you are researching already in mind, rather than just reading for general interest and knowledge.
Ideas are linked to other ideas by proximity in the text file rather than [[links]]. This is a limitation, but would be the same limitation encountered when eventually trying to publish a final piece.
Another thought is that individual zettels must eventually be copied into a single file to be combined into a finished piece of writing. Maybe it can be conceptualised that a Zettelkasten adds an extra layer of complexity to provide a higher level of organisation, where as using just one big text file gives more efficiency.
It seems like David Epstein used something similar to this while writing his book "Range"
Another very specific thing I’ve done for both books is create what I’ve called a “master thought list.” Just a document where I put down thoughts, quotes, questions, interesting tidbits from studies, and citations or links to interesting articles. And I sort of start organizing these into groups that address a common aspect of my core question. And as a group grows, I give it a “tag,” which is just a title, but I also jot a bunch of words that I think I might search if I wanted to get back to that idea cluster. And eventually, I move some of the tagged groups that are more alike toward one another, and it can become almost a bit like a rough storyboard. For Range, it ended up being like 60,000 words long, so it can get a little unwieldy, but I find that to be a useful process, and also it gives me this nice searchable space for ideas I’ve had and research I’ve done.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!